Download PDF The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden
Downloading and install guide The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden in this website listings could give you more advantages. It will reveal you the very best book collections and completed collections. Plenty books can be located in this internet site. So, this is not only this The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden Nevertheless, this book is referred to review because it is an inspiring publication to make you much more possibility to get experiences as well as ideas. This is easy, read the soft file of the book The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden as well as you get it.
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden
Download PDF The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden
Exactly what do you do to begin reading The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden Searching guide that you enjoy to read very first or discover an appealing book The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden that will make you would like to review? Everybody has distinction with their factor of reviewing a book The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden Actuary, reading routine should be from earlier. Many individuals might be love to read, but not a publication. It's not mistake. A person will certainly be bored to open the thick book with tiny words to read. In more, this is the actual condition. So do happen probably with this The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden
Yet, what's your concern not also enjoyed reading The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden It is a fantastic task that will always give wonderful advantages. Why you come to be so odd of it? Numerous things can be practical why people do not like to check out The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden It can be the uninteresting tasks, the book The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden collections to review, even lazy to bring nooks everywhere. But now, for this The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden, you will certainly start to love reading. Why? Do you recognize why? Read this page by finished.
Starting from seeing this site, you have actually attempted to start nurturing reviewing a book The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden This is specialized website that market hundreds compilations of books The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden from whole lots sources. So, you won't be tired anymore to choose guide. Besides, if you likewise have no time at all to browse guide The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden, simply sit when you remain in workplace as well as open up the browser. You could locate this The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden lodge this web site by attaching to the internet.
Obtain the connect to download this The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden as well as start downloading. You can really want the download soft documents of the book The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden by going through various other tasks. And that's all done. Now, your rely on read a book is not consistently taking and also bring guide The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden anywhere you go. You could conserve the soft data in your device that will certainly never ever be away as well as review it as you such as. It is like reading story tale from your gizmo after that. Currently, start to enjoy reading The Gray And The Black: The Confederate Debate On Emancipation, By Robert F. Durden and also get your brand-new life!
The Confederacy in its waning days turned to the idea of arming slaves, as leaders such as Jefferson Davis attempted to force the South to sacrifice one of its war aims - the preservation of slavery - in order to achieve an independent southern nation. This book reconstructs this passionate debate.
- Sales Rank: #1476620 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Louisiana State Univ Pr
- Published on: 2000-05-01
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.14" h x .67" w x 5.99" l, 1.01 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 305 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
About the Author
Robert F. Durden, professor of history emeritus at Duke University, is the author of many books, including The Climax of Populism: The Election of 1896.
Most helpful customer reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful.
Basic book on the Civil War
By Edison McIntyre
This isn't the best history book I've ever read -- indeed, purely as a reading experience it was not enjoyable. But as a work of scholarship that explores a complex and too-little-considered subject, Robert Durden's book is extremely informative and worth the time of any Civil War student who wants to go beyond the trumpets and drums to examine the true nature of the Confederate States of America.
Durden did not so much "write" as "compile" "The Gray and the Black." About 90 percent of the prose here consists of newspaper editorials, speeches, letters and other Civil War-era documents that express a variety of Confederate views on slavery and, specifically, on proposals made in the last two years of the war to arm and train Southern blacks as combat soldiers for the armies of the CSA. Durden focuses specifically on the efforts by Jefferson Davis and other Confederate leaders late in 1864 that led eventually to action by the Confederate Congress in March 1865. By then, of course, it was far too late for the few southern blacks who got into training to make any difference in the outcome of the war. Less than a month after the law was passed, Gen. Robert E. Lee surrendered his dwindling Confederate army at Appomattox Court House.
The book is most enlightening in illustrating the clash of opinions between those who, with some reluctance, saw the arming and training of black slaves as Confederate soldiers as the major hope for Southern military success after the fall of 1864, and other white Southerners who viewed the proposed transformation of blacks into combat troops as a betrayal of widely held theories of white supremacy that were used to justify black slavery. Durden also shows how legal questions of states' rights and property rights hampered efforts by Davis and others to enlist black soldiers for the Confederate cause, as well as the great awareness among most Confederates that the Union Army had enlisted large numbers of African-Americans to fight against them.
Although not its specific topic, this book is especially useful in countering arguments by present-day Confederate apologists who claim that Southern blacks served in the Confederate armies in large numbers. Certainly, many black Southerners did perform various non-combat jobs in Confederate service -- teamsters, cooks, hospital aides, body servants to white soldiers -- but the vehement controversy over arming black men to fight for the Confederacy, as portrayed by Durden, indicates that black combat soldiers in gray uniforms were a novelty -- or an anathema -- to most white Southerners. No doubt there were individual black or mulatto Southerners who fought with a certain Confederate unit on this occasion or that; but did these isolated incidences have any significant impact on the racial attitudes of white Southerners? Even among proponents of training blacks as combat troops, there is little evidence that their desperation to preserve Confederate independence had much influence on their overall sense of white supremacy. Even those who advocated freedom for slaves who would become Confederate soldiers were hardly ready to elevate free black men to a political and social status equal to that of white Confederate veterans. (Perhaps it should be noted that the racial attitudes of white Northerners also were little affected by the loyal service of 200,000 black Union soldiers.)
I am interested to see how this topic is treated in Bruce Levine's new study, "Confederate Emancipation," but "The Gray and the Black" will likely remain a valuable examination of the topic because of the wealth of primary source material Durden has accumulated here. Much of the 19th-century prose is dense and makes for hard slogging (but is fun to declaim aloud); and one wishes there were more, shorter chapters. Still, this is a basic book on the Civil War, one that not only illuminates the issue of Confederate emancipation efforts, but also sheds much light on the shifting racial attitudes of the Confederacy in its dying days.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
Could there have been a Confederacy without slavery?
By Stephen M. St Onge
Prof. Robert F. Durden here examines one of the Confederacy's little known episodes: the effort to recruit black slaves and freemen as Rebel soldiers.
Prof. Durden has, within limits, done an outstanding job of presenting the evidence on this controversy. He shows what people said at the time, and while he doesn't hesitate to let you know where he stands, he never mixes his judgements with the evidence.
I do have a few criticisms. Durden doesn't always print the documents in chronological order, resulting in potential confusion about what the state of opinion was when. And he relies far to much on 'official' sources, rather than the privately expressed views of Southerners in their letters and diaries.
That last is important because one of the great issues of the debate was what effect recruiting black soldiers would have on whites: would they stand for it? Durden quotes various memorials some soldiers made urging the govt. to recruit slaves as soldiers, but I wonder how many dissenting opinions were surpressed by the pressure of officers desperate for troops? James MacPherson's book WHAT THEY FOUGHT FOR suggests that the picture in the Confederate Army was not nearly as one sided as the one Durden's documents present.
There are many other fascinating questions worth pursuing in this area: how many blacks would have volunteered (some did), and how well would they have fought? If the fateful step had been taken in time, how would it have affected the war, and postwar relations between blacks and whites in the South? Durden doesn't attempt to answer these questions, but I wish someone would.
It's sad that after over thirty years so few have sought to follow Durden's pioneering inquiry. This book is still the only extended treatment of this subject I've found. But even if there were dozens, I believe I'd still recommend it highly. A very good work indeed.
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful.
The Finest Compendium of Civil War-Era Opinion
By A Customer
In a brilliant book unparalleled in quality, Professor Robert F. Durden provides the reader invaluable insight into the Confederate struggle over whether to free, and arm, their slaves.
This reviewer has read many history books and is a researcher by trade. The book is among--if not the--finest history book he has ever come across. Professor Durden acts as a genial host who introduces the individuals and context, and then steps back into the shadows to permit speeches, letters, and newspaper editorials describe, debate, and unfold. Professor Durden's selection of sources, incredibly well organized, clearly shows the debate over the question of the day: should the South arm the slaves, or should the slave states maintain their Southern "institutions" and perish?
This book is a critical resource for individuals interested in "Afro-Confederates" mentioned in other books, and trotted out at the drop of a confederate symbol. The book clearly indicates that the South depended upon its slave system both economically and politically, and many a southerner simply could not imagine Negroes as either Confederate citizens or armed troops. The leadership in much of the Confederacy could never tolerate the concept of Negro soldiers, and would not agree to free even those slaves who might volunteer. Yet by late 1864 many a white soldier in the ranks (including Lee) were apparently willing to accept reinforcements no matter the color. But Negroes in Virginia were not even permitted to carry arms until 1865, at the very sunset of the Rebellion. Those few souls organized at the end of the war never saw combat.
Without doubt the finest Civil War book read by this reviewer, there are no criticisms to levy. The "Gray and the Black" is impressively researched, with an excellent historiography and valuable index. The analysis, organization, thoughtfulness and dedication that went into this book are humbling. Those that purchase this book will be thrilled and enlightened.
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden PDF
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden EPub
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden Doc
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden iBooks
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden rtf
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden Mobipocket
The Gray and the Black: The Confederate Debate on Emancipation, by Robert F. Durden Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar